What If Dak Prescott Left Dallas? A Hypothetical Look at Life After No. 4
Dak Prescott has been the face of the Dallas Cowboys for nearly a decade. Drafted in 2016, he went from a fourth-round backup to the franchise quarterback under center for America’s Team. But as with every star player, the question eventually arises — what would happen if he left?
Whether it’s due to contract negotiations, performance concerns, or a change in organizational direction, imagining a Cowboys future without Dak isn’t just speculation — it’s a conversation more fans are beginning to have.
Here’s what could unfold if Dak Prescott walked away from Dallas.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/70459652/usa_today_17517219.0.jpg)
Immediate Chaos and Uncertainty
Let’s be honest — losing a franchise quarterback doesn’t come without chaos. Dak has been the leader of the locker room, a consistent on-field performer, and a stabilizing presence during turbulent years. Without him, Dallas would instantly enter quarterback limbo — something they haven’t had to deal with since the post-Tony Romo era.
The Cowboys currently have no proven long-term replacement. Cooper Rush and Trey Lance are on the roster, but neither has shown the ability to be a full-time starter capable of leading a Super Bowl-caliber team.
Without Dak, the team would either:
-
Draft a QB early, which comes with growing pains
-
Trade for a veteran, which costs draft capital and cap space
-
Or roll with a backup, which signals a rebuilding year
None of these options guarantee a better future than keeping Prescott.
Fallout in the Locker Room
Prescott is more than just a quarterback — he’s a leader, a mentor, and a voice that teammates trust. His departure would leave a major leadership vacuum. Young players like CeeDee Lamb and Micah Parsons have grown under Dak’s guidance, and his absence could disrupt team chemistry.
The locker room might divide between those who believed in him and those ready to move on. And without a clear new leader, morale could suffer — especially if the losses pile up.
The Jerry Jones Factor
Owner Jerry Jones has been loyal to Dak — but he’s also a businessman. If he were to let Dak walk, it would likely be part of a larger shift in vision. Whether that means a complete rebuild or a splashy move for another QB, Jones wouldn’t stay silent for long.
Expect media headlines, speculation, and pressure like never before.
And let’s face it — if Dak leaves and finds success elsewhere (especially a Super Bowl), Jerry’s decision will age poorly in the eyes of the public and fans.
A New Era, for Better or Worse
Sometimes, bold moves pay off. If the Cowboys were to land a young star in the draft or acquire a top-tier veteran QB (think someone like Justin Fields, Kyler Murray, or even a surprise name), the team could spark a new era of excitement.
But it’s a gamble.
Moving on from a steady performer like Prescott in hopes of something “better” is a high-risk, high-reward play. For every team that lands the next Patrick Mahomes, there’s another left wandering the desert of QB uncertainty for years (just ask the Jets or Commanders).
For Dak: New Team, New Fire
From Dak’s side, a departure could rejuvenate his career.
If he landed on a team with a strong offensive line, elite weapons, and a coach who builds around his strengths — like the Falcons, Vikings, or even the Steelers — he could thrive and silence critics who believe he can’t win the big one.
Imagine Dak Prescott returning to AT&T Stadium in a different jersey… and beating the Cowboys in a playoff game. That storyline writes itself.
Conclusion: Be Careful What You Wish For
There’s a segment of Cowboys fans ready to move on. They want a Super Bowl and don’t believe Dak is the one to bring it home. But sometimes, in chasing perfection, teams lose something invaluable — stability, leadership, and reliability.
Prescott may not have reached the mountaintop yet, but his presence has kept the Cowboys competitive, consistent, and hopeful every season. Without him, there are no guarantees — only question marks.
So if Dak Prescott ever does leave Dallas, the Cowboys won’t just lose a quarterback.
They’ll lose their foundation.
And whether that’s a turning point or a long fall from grace… only time will tell.
